Comprehensive Comparison
New India Assurance vs Star Health and Allied Insurance: Which is Better in 2026?
Compare New India Assurance and Star Health and Allied Insurance health insurance - claim settlement, network hospitals, premiums, and customer ratings to find the best insurer for you.
New India vs Star Health: Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | New India | Star Health |
|---|---|---|
| Claim Settlement Ratio | 92.9% ★ | 91.2% |
| Network Hospitals | 7,500+ | 14,200+ ★ |
| Customer Rating | 3.9/5 | 4.4/5 |
| Avg. Premium (Individual) | ₹5,000/yr ★ | ₹9,000/yr |
| Years in Business | 107 years Since 1919 | 20 years Since 2006 |
| Headquarters | Mumbai | Chennai |
| Type | Psu | Standalone |
| Best For | Family Floater
Individual
Group | Senior Citizen
Family Floater
Individual |
New India Assurance
Star Health and Allied Insurance
Our Verdict
Star Health for better service. New India for lowest premiums with government backing.
Choose New India if:
[Budget is primary concern You trust government insurers Lowest premium needed Basic coverage sufficient]
Choose Star Health if:
[Service quality matters Better claim settlement needed You want dedicated health insurer Premium hospitals access needed]
Can't Decide? Get Expert Help
Our advisors can help you choose based on your specific needs
Top New India Plans
Get New India QuoteTop Star Health Plans
Star Comprehensive
Young Star
Senior Citizen Red Carpet
New India Assurance vs Star Health and Allied Insurance: Detailed Comparison
Claim Settlement
New India has a claim settlement ratio of 92.9% while Star Health settles 91.2% of claims. New India has a slight edge in this crucial metric.
Network Hospitals
New India has 7,500+ hospitals while Star Health has 14,200+ hospitals. Star Health offers a wider network for cashless claims.
Premium Comparison
For individual plans, New India starts at ₹5,000/year while Star Health starts at ₹9,000/year. New India is more affordable.
Best For
- New India: Family floater, individual, group
- Star Health: Senior citizen, family floater, individual
New India vs Star Health FAQs
Why Trust AskBima?
IRDAI licensed | Trusted by 50,000+ customers